Landmark Victorian home in Cape May will come out of Sea Mist
By RICHARD DEGENER Staff Writer, (609) 463-6711
Press of Atlantic City
Published: Wednesday, June 27, 2007
CAPE MAY — “When was the fire?” asks a summer tourist peddling a surrey down Beach Avenue on Tuesday morning.
A neighbor to The Sea Mist, the landmark four-story Victorian on the beachfront said to be the most photographed structure in Cape May, has to tell somebody for the umpteenth time there was no fire.
What began as a simple renovation to the 1873 landmark has, well, gotten more complicated. It happens with old buildings. Much of the structure is now in a dumpster.
The good news is the new owners say that by next summer the town will have a new Sea Mist that looks just like the old Sea Mist.
“We had to do a more extreme deconstruction than we planned. We're anxious to bring it back to what we think it should be, a landmark,” said Barry Sharer, one of the principals in the company Sea Mist Cape May, LLC.
Sharer and his partners bought the Sea Mist last year with plans to turn the 15-unit apartment complex into eight condominiums. The units will range from $479,000 for a one bedroom to $2,299,000 for the fourth floor penthouse.
It would have cost simply $350,000 to replace the structure. The renovation was originally expected to cost $1.3 million, but that estimate is rising fast.
Renovations are always more expensive than new construction, but in this case, rotten wood and foundation issues complicated matters. It was originally a two-story house with an attic. A third and fourth floor, several additions and decks, were added to the structure.
“There was a lot of added weight put on the foundation it wasn't designed to handle,” Sharer said.
The job now includes new piling, footings and steel girders. None of that will be visible on the outside when the new cedar clapboard is nailed on next year. There will be trim and columns made of Cyprus wood. No vinyl siding. It will be painted. An artist's rendering at the site shows the same red and white coloring, and all five decks are still there overlooking the ocean.
Neighbors were happy to hear that. The Sea Mist has been featured in commercials touting New Jersey's tourism industry. It has been in national magazines and on a New Jersey lottery ticket.
“It's good for business. I can't tell you how many people stop and ask about this. It's helped tourism so much,” said next-door neighbor Kate Egan
The Egans have been next door since 1965 and have old photographs when The Sea Mist was just another two-story house on the beach. They credit the late Fred Morrison, who bought it after the 1962 storm, with turning it into the most picturesque building in a town full of picturesque buildings.
“Fred built it by hand,” said Mary Louise Egan.
Much of what he built was recently removed under a partial demolition permit. City Construction Official William Callahan hasn't heard the end of it.
“My phone rings every day, and they think it's a fire or a bomb hit it,” Callahan said.
The city takes some flak, but Callahan said in the end the structure will conform to modern building codes but with the same look and design of the original. Callahan noted the city's Historic Preservation Commission approved the plans. He said his whole office staff worked on it, putting in twice as much time as normal.
“If it ends up like it was, we'll all be heroes. If it doesn't, they'll kill me,” Callahan said.
Sharer said demolition work is complete and a framing crew should be rebuilding as early as this Thursday.
That will please Glenn McBrearty, a contractor working next door at the Beach Guest House. He admired what is left of The Sea Mist on Tuesday.
“It will look great when they're done, a grand old dame,” McBrearty said.
There will be some minor changes. Callahan said the front awning will span the front of the structure instead of going out towards the beach. Sharer said the columns were four inches square and they will be upgraded to eight inches square. Parking will be moved from the front lawn to the back of the structure. There will be a fire escape in the back and an elevator in the building. There are also lighting changes to highlight the building at night.
To e-mail Richard Degener at The Press:RDegener@pressofac.com