Forecast Turns Bit Cloudier
The Philadelphia Inquirer; 6/26/2006
Jun. 26--Without a doubt, the Jersey Shore real estate market has had a fantastic run for the last eight years. Up and down the coastline, from the top of Ocean County to the tip of Cape May, construction boomed, sales exploded and prices skyrocketed.
Stories abound of overnight fortunes made by investors, like the one who flipped an Ocean City property in one day last year and made a $540,000 profit on a $4.1 million house.
An Inquirer analysis of 27,709 home sales last year in Atlantic, Cape May and Ocean Counties showed that about 1,000 houses sold for $1 million or more.
And five towns -- Stone Harbor and Avalon in Cape May County and Bay Head, Harvey Cedars and Mantoloking in Ocean County -- had median home prices of $1 million or more, the analysis showed. (The median is the middle value; half the houses sold for more, half sold for less. In any town, a drop in median price does not mean prices fell for all houses there.)
But this picture of sunny times is turning partly cloudy, observers of the Shore market say, as higher interest rates are beginning to dampen sales, and condo construction, mostly involving investors, adds to a growing surplus of properties.
"Whenever interest rates rise, the second-home market is the first one to take the hit," said Fred Glick, president of US Loans Mortgage L.L.C. in Philadelphia.
Long-term rates climbed to 6.71 percent Thursday, Freddie Mac reported, the highest since May 31, 2002. Adjustable-rate mortgages are at 6.4 percent.
"It's the condo and lower end of the Shore market that's taking a hit," said Paul Leiser, a broker at Avalon Real Estate. "These are the buyers who depend on lower interest rates to balance two mortgages, and with rising interest rates, they can't do it.
"We've sold fewer units, but our dollar volume in the first quarter was higher than it was in the first quarter of 2005, which was a record year," Leiser said. "It's the million-dollar-house purchases that push up the medians, and those are usually cash. And when you are talking about million-dollar houses, consider that an older rancher three blocks from the beach in Stone Harbor is $1.4 million."
The Inquirer's analysis showed the median price of homes in the three counties grew at a slower pace in 2005, to $274,000, a 16 percent increase over 2004 compared to a 21 percent jump the year before.
Only Atlantic County was able to maintain the same rate of growth from 2004 to 2005; its median home price rose 24 percent, to $223,357.
In Cape May County, the year-over-year median gain was less than half the increase experienced a year earlier. The median was up 11 percent in 2005, to $391,000, compared to a 26 percent gain in 2004.
Ocean County's median grew 15 percent in 2005 compared to 20 percent in 2004.
Fewer than 200 more houses were sold in 2005 than in 2004, an indication of declining demand. Another sign: Thirty-one municipalities had median increases of more than 20 percent in 2005, compared with 44 in 2004.
Although sales comparisons for the first quarters of 2006 and 2005 from the New Jersey Division of Taxation were incomplete, indications are that the market appears to be slowing further this year.
Sales in Cape May and Ocean Counties in the first quarter of 2006 were lower by a couple hundred sales each than in the first quarter of 2005. Atlantic County sales were a bit higher.
Market observers said Atlantic County, which for the last several years has been evolving into a bedroom community for Atlantic City, also is fast becoming a suburb of Philadelphia.
Major developers such as D.R. Horton, K. Hovnanian, and Ryan Homes have been building single-family developments and active-adult communities -- not necessarily with ocean views.
"We call them 'off-shore vs. on-shore,' " said Jerome DiPentino, broker at Premier Properties Real Estate in Longport. "More and more people are choosing to live here year-round, and that is stabilizing the market, although high-end sales in Margate and Longport also have been skewing the median upward."
Things don't seem as rosy in Ocean City, the scene of numerous teardowns and massive development since the mid-1990s. As of mid-June, there were more than 1,700 listings on the Ocean City Multiple Listing Service (MLS).
"They're saying that Ocean City is overbuilt by two years," DiPentino said. "That may be conservative."
Jay Lamont, the host of "All About Real Estate" on WPEN-AM (950), who has studied and owned real estate in Ocean City for about 40 years, said, "I have never seen anything even close to this debacle. Many legitimate and qualified buyers are waiting for fall, for the lender REO [real-estate-owned] listings and foreclosure sales on failed developer loans."
Weekly sales reported to the Ocean City MLS are 80 percent to 90 percent lower than they were in spring 2005, with seven or eight sales a week, he said.
What's going on?
"The short-term investors at the Shore were in the condo market primarily, and they're the ones pulling out," said Mark Zandi, chief economist at Moody's Economy.com in West Chester. "They don't buy multimillion-dollar homes."
(In Ocean City, condos made up a little more than half the 1,314 sales in 2005, The Inquirer analysis showed. The median condo price: $529,950, up 14 percent from 2004.)
Oversupply also seems to be a problem elsewhere in Cape May County.
Paul Schlimme, vice president of MLS Realty in Cherry Hill, said that between Jan. 1 and May 31 there were 189 listings on the Avalon MLS, with about nine houses selling per month.
"That means there is a 21-month supply in Avalon, and it is getting worse," Schlimme said. By mid-June, 29 new single-family houses were listed, and just 13 sold, "which means there are 16 more properties competing..."
Over the course of the 1998-2005 Shore boom, Wildwood, West Wildwood, and North Wildwood registered a more than 250 percent increase in median prices, The Inquirer analysis showed. (So did Stone Harbor, Longport, Avalon and Harvey Cedars.)
The Wildwoods, too, were a draw for investors, who razed motels and filled empty tracts with condos. But with for-sale signs sprouting and interest apparently tailing off, that boom could be over, local market experts say.
With summer here, the Shore market could get even slower.
In Ocean City, Lamont said, "open houses are held each weekend, sometimes as many as eight per block on Asbury Avenue, with almost no legitimate buyer traffic showing up even to use the bathrooms."
How This Analysis Was Conducted
The Inquirer's home-price analysis was based on nearly 250,000 residential sales in 2004 and 2005. Home-sale information was obtained from the five Pennsylvania counties and the New Jersey Division of Taxation.
Only sales at fair-market prices of $10,000 or greater were included in the analysis of single-family homes, condominiums, townhouses, and twins, or duplexes.
The median home price is the amount at which half the sale prices are more and half are less. The percentage change reflects the difference in the median price from 2004 to 2005.
A town with fewer than 10 sales is marked "N.C." because the median and percentage change were not calculated. Towns with no sales are marked "N.S."
All numbers are rounded to the closest whole number.
Contact real estate writer Alan J. Heavens at 215-854-2472 or aheavens@phillynews.com.
-----
Copyright (c) 2006, The Philadelphia Inquirer